
Mayer Hawthorne – A Strange Arrangement (Fall 2009)
NOTE: Instead of giving it a 5 mic/star kind of thing I am going to do something a little familiar and a little different.
Grade: 79
Day(s) of Week to Spin: Saturday, Monday
There are different feelings that could bring one to either love this record… or feel completely the opposite. The reason is simple; “Arrangement” feels like something that would have been comfortably slated for a fall release… in 1969. A very ballad-heavy project; emotionally charged lyrics and some dance-provoking sets would normally promise a very soulful, Motown-esque record. “Arrangement” however lacks originality and depth of feeling. It also is not very convincing in the way of delivery. The “not-really-singing” sound of Mayer Hawthorne’s voice works well for what the song writing accomplished, however the record as a whole fails to show much range or depth to his voice. The title track is one of the stronger tracks on the record along with the official single “Just Ain’t Gonna Work Out” and “Shiny & New” also standing out amongst several short falsetto-driven ballads.
Upon first listen to this project one would (on average) more than likely abandon any thoughts of consuming this record in its entirety, however, after listening to the record repeatedly, it begins to grow on the “soul singer” in you. Picture black and white television and slender band mates two stepping in front of microphones with a plain backdrop. Then the phone rings and you realize you’re just sitting there in front of the 13 inch Macbook.
Most people tend to be more comfortable with music that they can place within a genre; people tend to want to compare music to other music and often use other artists as reference point. With this Hawthorne album, it would be really difficult to find a place to put a physical copy of it, as the first whim that comes to mind is to stick it between a David Ruffin record and Eddie Kendricks record. Unfortunately, I don’t have a vinyl copy of this record. I said that to say this: “Arrangement” evokes the feeling of a quiet morning house cleaning; having woke up early as 9 a.m. and dropping the needle and grabbing a broom. There not being a lot of music out today to compare it with makes it stand out in my book… and makes it completely irrelevant in the (ears) minds of others.
All in all I enjoyed the album, but I feel like it would be totally hit or miss depending on who you give the album to. It probably could enjoyed most by a beat maker or a 70-something year old couple trying to rekindle what being young and in love felt like. In case I’m giving you too much credit for being intelligent; you realize that those are two extreme demographics and any project that can be enjoyed that expansively is, overall, a solid project in my book.
More Mayer Hawthorne: Stonesthrow | Myspace | enjoy!
Review by: know:juander
No Comments | In: Album Review, CS Exclusive | tags: album, arrangement, hawthorne, mayer, review, soul, stonesthrow, strange. | #